Order of Distribution of Court Costs in Cases Challenging the Results of Cadastral Value Determination
Having regard to the fact that Chapter 25 of the Code of Administrative Procedure of the Russian Federation does not establish any particularities in the distribution of judicial expenses in cases concerning disputes over the results of cadastral valuation, the issue of judicial expenses incurred by the applicant, administrative plaintiff, interested party, or administrative defendant is resolved in accordance with the rules provided in Chapter 10 of the Code of Administrative Procedure of the Russian Federation.
If the court satisfies the claims regarding establishing the market value of a real estate object, judicial expenses are recovered from the authority that approved the results of the cadastral valuation.
However, in cases where satisfying such claims amounts to realizing in court the applicant's or administrative plaintiff's right to establish the cadastral value at the level of market value, which is not disputed by the interested party or administrative defendant involved in the case neither as to the grounds for its emergence nor as to its content (including the size of the market value), judicial expenses are charged to the applicant or administrative plaintiff, since the court's decision on the relevant case cannot be regarded as having been adopted against the interested party or administrative defendant who does not have opposing legal interests with the applicant or administrative plaintiff.
In cases where claims for challenging the results of cadastral valuation are satisfied due to the inaccuracy of information about the object of appraisal, including in connection with the correction of a cadastral error in the data, judicial expenses are recovered from the authority that approved the results of state cadastral valuation.
If the cadastral value was revised due to a technical error in the information about the object of appraisal, judicial expenses are charged to the authority which committed such an error.
In cases where claims for challenging the decision or actions (inaction) of the Commission are satisfied, judicial expenses are recovered from the state authority under which the Commission is established, at the expense of the Russian Federation treasury (fourth paragraph of Article 24.18 of the Law on Appraisal Activities).
Choose a reaction, rate the material, and tell us what could be improved.