Subject and Method of Land Law. Land as an Object of Legal Regulation
Is this topic interesting to you?
Test yourself
Право
Short questions will help you recall the key points of the document.
Loading questions…
Test yourself
Short questions will help you recall the key points of the document.
Loading questions…
Land law has a separate subject and a special method of regulation, combining public and private elements, and land as an object of law possesses a complex multi-faceted nature.
We will now consider the above issues in detail.
According to general legal theory, the criteria for dividing law into separate branches are the subject and method of legal regulation. If the subject answers the question of which relations are regulated by law, then the method answers the question of how this regulation is carried out1. In legal theory and practice, the terms "branch of law" and "branch of legislation" are used as non-identical. From a philosophical perspective, the system of law and the system of legislation relate to each other as content and form. The system of legislation is an expression of the system of law, its objective form2.
The main factor determining the distinction between one branch of law and another is the subject of legal regulation, that is, a qualitatively homogeneous type of social relations regulated by the corresponding branch of law, their uniqueness3. Social relations are relations between people concerning objects of the material world, related to their use4. These relations have the following characteristics: 1) they are vital for a person and his or her associations; 2) they are volitional, purposeful (rational) relations; 3) they are stable, recurring, and typical relations; 4) they are behavioral relations, for which external control can be exercised (for example, by judicial authorities)5. Each branch of law has its own sphere of legal regulation, accordingly, it also has its own subject of legal regulation6.
Land legislation regulates relations concerning the use and protection of land in the Russian Federation as the basis for the life and activities of the peoples living on the corresponding territory (paragraph 1 of Article 3 of the Land Code of the Russian Federation). This provision is based on the provisions of part 1 of Article 9 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation, according to which land and other natural resources are used and protected in the Russian Federation as the basis for the life and activities of the peoples living on the corresponding territory.
Based on the provisions of Russian Federation legislation presented above, it can be concluded that the subject of land law and legislation are land relations (i.e., relations arising in connection with the use and protection of land). Land relations, as a general rule, are not regulated by other branches of law. Norms from other branches of law (primarily civil and administrative) may regulate land relations to the extent that these relations are not regulated by land law (for example, in the part of filling gaps in land legal regulation).
Land relations are: vital for a person and his associations; volitional, purposeful (rational); stable, recurring and typical; behavioral, for which external control can be exercised (e.g., by judicial authorities). Thus, land law has a self-contained subject of legal regulation.
It is important to note that other views on the independence of land law are expressed in literature. According to V.A. Dozortsev "... land relations have been divided into those regulated by civil and administrative law, so the grounds for recognizing land law as an independent branch no longer exist; now land has fallen within the scope of civil law, being an object of economic circulation."7 This argument cannot be considered valid, since land has a complex legal regime and is simultaneously a natural object, a natural resource, and at the same time immovable property.
An additional basis for dividing the law into branches is considered to be the method of legal regulation, which represents a set of methods and ways of regulating social relations, influencing human behavior8. The most common and polar in their characteristics are the imperative and dispositional methods. The imperative method is based on subordination relationships, the subjugation of some legal subjects to others. It is characteristic of administrative law, executive criminal law9. The imperative method provides for the regulation of participants' behavior through the establishment of a rule of conduct, which must be unconditionally performed. Participants in the corresponding legal relations are not allowed to change this rule of conduct at their own discretion. The imperative method is a manifestation of public principles in law and is characterized by vertical relationships, which are also called subordination relationships or relationships of authority and submission.
Example of an imperative norm: "when adjacent land plots are merged, a single land plot is formed, and the existence of such adjacent land plots ceases" (paragraph 1 of article 11.6 of the Russian Federation Land Code). The cited norm provides only one consequence of merging adjacent land plots. Participants in the relevant legal relationship do not have the possibility to change at their own discretion the consequences of merging adjacent land plots.
The dispositional method implies equality of the parties and is applied in areas of private law (civil, labor, family)10. The dispositional method provides for the regulation of the behavior of participants in legal relations through the establishment of a rule of conduct that can be modified by the parties to the legal relationship at their own discretion, independently, within the limits defined by the corresponding legal norm. The dispositional method is an expression of private principles in law; it is characterized by horizontal relationships based on the autonomy of will of the participants in the legal relationship. A dispositional norm can often be identified by the phrase "unless otherwise provided for in the contract." A dispositional norm allows the parties to provide for another order of regulation of the relevant relations in the contract. If the parties do not do so, the norm provided for by law will apply.
The dispositional method provides participants in legal relations with the opportunity to independently determine possible options for behavior. For example, a dispositional norm may provide for a certain rule of conduct and include the phrase "unless otherwise provided by the contract". This allows the parties to provide for another order of regulation of the relevant relations in the contract, and if the parties do not do so, then the norm provided for by law will apply. What is interesting here is that in both cases, from the moment of conclusion of the contract, this norm becomes imperative.
An example of a dispositional norm: "it is permissible to merge a land plot encumbered by a mortgage with a land plot not encumbered by a mortgage. In this case, the mortgage right extends to the entire newly formed land plot, unless otherwise provided for in an agreement between the parties" (paragraph 6 of article 11.6 of the Russian Federation Land Code). The norm provided above provides autonomy of will for participants in the relevant legal relationship, meaning that the parties may provide for other consequences of merging the respective land plots in their agreement. If the parties do not include such a provision in the agreement, the rule of conduct established by the legal norm will apply.
The imperative method of legal regulation has a public-law nature; it is characterized by vertical power and subordination relationships. The dispositional method has a private-law nature; it is characterized by horizontal relationships based on the autonomy of will of participants in legal relations.
Land law regulates the behavior of participants in land relations through a special combination of imperative and discretionary methods of influencing people's behavior. The predominant method of influencing people's conduct in land law is the imperative one. In this regard, it should be noted that the method of land law is imperative-discretionary with the predominance of the imperative.
At the same time, new combinations of imperative and dispositif modes of regulation are emerging. In public spheres where equality between parties traditionally does not exist, elements of private law, related to contractual and consensual procedures, are increasingly penetrating, while elements of public law are more widely present and applied in the sphere of private law. There remains a need to search for an optimal combination of legal influence methods11. The doctrinal opposition between private and public law does not withstand the test of modern realities12. For example, in the first and second parts of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation, among the norms regulating certain types of contracts, there are about 1600 imperative provisions and only about 200 dispositif ones13, while dispositivity is present in the sphere of criminal law regulation14.
Land law includes elements of both public and private law, legal institutes that have both sectoral (land law) and inter-sectoral legal nature (for example - legal liability for land violations).
Thus, land law affects people's behavior by combining imperative and dispositional methods of legal regulation based on the understanding of land as a natural object, natural resource and real estate.
The principles of land legislation are defined in paragraph 1 of article 1 of the Land Code of the Russian Federation. Subparagraph 1 of the aforementioned article defines the principle of taking into account the importance of land as the basis of life and activity of a person. According to this principle, regulation of relations regarding the use and protection of land is carried out based on the following views of land: 1) as a natural object protected as an important component of nature; 2) as a natural resource used as a means of production in agriculture and forestry and the basis for carrying out economic and other activities within the territory of the Russian Federation; 3) at the same time as immovable property, as an object of ownership and other rights to land.
The view of land as a natural object15 is based on the fact that land is one of the components of the natural environment (article 1 of Federal Law No. 7-FZ dated January 10, 2002 "On Environmental Protection"), which is subject to protection (protection of land is devoted to Chapter II of the Land Code of the Russian Federation).
The view of land as a natural resource16 is based on the fact that land is the main means of production in agriculture and forestry.
The view of land as real estate17 is based on the fact that land and other natural resources can be transferred or passed from one person to another in various ways to the extent permitted by laws on land and other natural resources (paragraph 3 of Article 129 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation).
The aforementioned views of land are interconnected. This means that when regulating relations within the framework of one view of land, we cannot ignore the other.
The land legislation establishes the priority of land protection as an important component of the environment and a means of production in agriculture and forestry over the use of land as real estate, according to which ownership, use, and disposal of land are carried out freely by landowners, provided that this does not cause harm to the environment (subparagraph 2 of paragraph 1 of article 1 of the Land Code of the Russian Federation).
The combination of imperative and dispositive norms of land law unites the general object of legal regulation, which is land.
409.
Theory of the state and law: textbook / ed. by A. S. Pigolkin. Moscow: Yurait-Izdat, 2006. P. 356. ↩
General theory of law and the state / ed. by V. V. Lazarev. Moscow: Yurist, 2001. P. 143. ↩
Theory of the state and law / ed. by A. S. Pigolkin. Moscow, 2006. P. 356–357. ↩
Krassov O. I. Environmental Law: textbook. M.: Norma, 2008. P. 33. ↩
Theory of the State and Law / ed. by S. S. Alekseev. M., 2004. ↩
Vlasenko N. A. Theory of the State and Law: a study guide. M.: Prospekt, 2011. P. 237. ↩
Dozortsev V. A. Issues of improving civil law of the Russian Federation during the transition to a market economy // State and Law. 1994. P. 26. ↩
Theory of the State and Law / ed. by A. S. Pigolkhin. M., 2006. P. 356–357. ↩
Theory of the State and Law / ed. by S. S. Alekseev. M., 2004. ↩
Theory of the State and Law / ed. by S. S. Alekseev. M., 2004. ↩
Theory of the state and law in science, education, practice: monograph / Ed. by T.Ya. Khabriyev / Institute of Legislation and Comparative Law under the Government of the Russian Federation; Moscow State University of Justice named after O.E. Kutafin (MGYuA). Moscow, 2016. P. 285. ↩
Theory of the state and law in science, education, practice / ed. by T.Ya. Khabriyev. Moscow, 2016. P. ↩
Braginsky M., Vityrinskii V.V. Contractual law. Book one. General provisions. Access mode: reference-legal system "KonsultantPlus". ↩
Sumachev A.V. Dispositive in criminal law (theoretical and applied analysis): abstract of dissertation ... doctor of legal sciences). Yekaterinburg, 2006. ↩
Natural object - a natural ecological system, natural landscape and the elements composing them that have retained their natural properties (Article 1 of the Federal Law dated January 10, 2002 No. 7-FZ "On Environmental Protection"). ↩
Natural resources are components of the natural environment, natural objects and nature-technogenic objects that are used or may be used in economic and other activities as sources of energy, production products and consumer goods and have consumer value (Article 1 of the Federal Law dated January 10, 2002 No. 7-FZ "On Environmental Protection"). ↩
Immovable property (real estate) includes land plots, subsoil plots and everything that is firmly connected to the ground, i.e., objects whose removal without disproportionate damage to their purpose is impossible, including buildings, structures, and unfinished construction objects (paragraph 1 of Article 130 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation). ↩
Choose a reaction, rate the material, and tell us what could be improved.