Publications

The establishment of functional zones within the boundaries of a special protected natural territory must be adequately substantiated.


Your opinion

Is this topic interesting to you?

Rating

When designating functional zones within the boundaries of a protected natural area, appropriate justification for establishing such zoning must be provided.

The owners of land plots included by the government decree of the subject of the Russian Federation on the creation of an ecological park with regional significance within the boundaries of this protected natural area approached the court with a claim to declare the aforementioned decree invalid in part concerning the functional zoning of the protected natural area.

In satisfying the stated claim, the court relied on the following.

For lands of protected natural areas, in order to preserve unique and typical natural complexes and objects, as well as plant and animal world objects, a special legal regime of their use is established, limiting economic activity (paragraphs 1, 2 of article 94 of the Land Code of the Russian Federation, preamble of the Law on Protected Natural Areas).

The law on protected natural areas of the subject of the Russian Federation where the disputed land plots are located provides that within the territory of ecological parks functional zones with different protection and use regimes are designated depending on the ecological and cultural value of individual natural complexes and objects.

One of the documents approved by the contested decree contains a textual description of two functional zones: protective and economic. The protective zone does not allow for economic activity and is aimed at preserving the natural environment in its natural state, as well as preserving and restoring ecosystems. The economic zone provides for the possibility of using and preserving capital construction objects on land plots allocated for individual housing construction prior to the establishment of the protected natural area.

The court, including taking into account the conclusion of judicial environmental expertise, established that at the time when work began on the project to create the protected natural area, there were capital construction objects in its southwestern part, including those owned by persons who filed the respective claim with the court; however, an economic zone was not designated for these objects, while such a zone was designated for similar objects in the northwestern part taking into account the historically established location of gardening societies.

Thus, land plots within the boundaries of the protected natural area with similar characteristics regarding territory development have been assigned to functional zones with different protection and use regimes. At the same time, justification for such functional zoning has not been provided.

Source: Thematic Review of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation No. 11/2026. On consideration by courts of cases related to rights on land plots of certain categories of lands removed from circulation and restricted in circulation, and use of such plots

Your opinion

How useful was this material to you?

Choose a reaction, rate the material, and tell us what could be improved.

Your impression
Rating
Select a star to rate it