Publications

Exclusion of a land plot from the boundaries of protected natural territories (OOPT) is permitted only upon confirmation of the loss of its special significance for the entire territory.


Your opinion

Is this topic interesting to you?

Rating

To exclude a land plot from the boundaries of a protected natural territory that has lost its scientific, cultural, aesthetic, and other special significance, it is necessary to determine the value and purpose of the excluded part in relation to the entire protected natural territory.

A citizen challenged the decision of the city council dated 2023, which introduced changes to the resolution adopted in 2009 on the establishment of a local-value protected natural territory in the form of a protected landscape, specifically regarding the exclusion from the boundaries of this protected natural territory of a land plot with an area of 5.3 hectares.

In this regard, the citizen stated that there were no grounds for such changes, as the excluded land plot is located in the economic zone, ensures the minimization of anthropogenic impact on adjacent forest areas, its exclusion does not meet the objectives and tasks of creating a protected natural territory, removes restrictions on economic activities carried out on it, which will contribute to an increase in anthropogenic load and the degree of degradation of the ecosystem of the protected natural territory.

Having established the absence of data indicating the loss by the excluded area of its special scientific, cultural, aesthetic, and other significance, the court concluded that the challenged decision did not comply with federal and regional legislation, and therefore annulled it in the disputed part.

The court also pointed out that the loss by a part of the protected natural territory of its special scientific, cultural, aesthetic, and other significance should be determined in relation to the objectives, functions, and tasks for which the protected natural territory was created, specifically those tasks and functions for which this area was included in the protected natural territory. At the same time, it is necessary to establish the inability of this part of the territory to perform the tasks assigned to it in relation to the territory of the protected natural territory and the impossibility of restoring its qualitative characteristics (Preamble, paragraph 1 of Article 2 of the Law on Protected Natural Territories).

Thus, examining the excluded part of the territory of the protected natural area in isolation from the entire territory of the protected natural area and its purpose cannot serve as a basis for concluding that this part of the protected natural area has lost its special scientific, cultural, aesthetic, and other significance.

In the considered case, the court established that an assessment of the value of the excluded part of the territory from the disputed protected natural territory in relation to the entire natural complex was not conducted. The data contained in the expert opinion submitted to the court do not confirm the loss by the excluded part of the protected natural territory of its special scientific, cultural, aesthetic, and other significance.

An unjustified exclusion of a part of the territory from the protected natural area does not correspond to the objectives of creating the protected natural area and the functional zoning of such an area.

Source: Thematic Review by the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation No. 11/2026. On the consideration by courts of cases related to the rights to land plots of certain categories of land removed from circulation and restricted in circulation, and on the use of such plots

Your opinion

How useful was this material to you?

Choose a reaction, rate the material, and tell us what could be improved.

Your impression
Rating
Select a star to rate it