In the presence of a dispute regarding rights, the priority of EGRN data over GLR data is not applied automatically
Resolving contradictions between data in EGRN and GLR through administrative procedures is possible in the absence of a dispute over property rights.
The company submitted an application to the ministry of forestry and protection of wildlife objects of the subject of the Russian Federation (hereinafter referred to as the ministry) requesting changes to the GLR and aligning forest plot boundaries with EGRN data, citing the intersection of boundaries of land plots owned by the company in the category "agricultural lands" with forest district boundaries.
The ministry refused to satisfy the application, stating that decisions regarding the transfer of state forest fund lands intersecting with the company's land plots into other categories had not been made in accordance with established procedures.
Considering the ministry's refusal unlawful, the company turned to court.
Courts denied the claim, relying on the priority of EGRN data over GLR data, taking into account that rights to the land plot arose before January 1, 2016.
The judicial collegium of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation overturned the judicial acts adopted in the case and referred the matter for reconsideration due to the following reasons.
According to paragraph 3 of Article 14 of the Law on the Transfer of Land or Land Plots from One Category to Another (as amended by Law No. 280-FZ dated July 29, 2017), if, in accordance with GLR data and the subject's forest plan, a land plot belongs to the category of forest fund lands, while according to EGRN data or land plots' title documents it is classified as belonging to another land category, the classification of the land plot shall be determined based on EGRN data or information from title documents, provided such information is not present in this register, except for cases specified in paragraph 6 of the aforementioned article. The provisions of this paragraph apply when rights of the owner or previous owners to a land plot arose before January 1, 2016.
Thus, provisions of Law No. 280-FZ dated July 29, 2017 establish an administrative procedure for resolving contradictions between data in two public registers (EGRN and GLR) and conditions under which EGRN data are given priority.
At the same time, these provisions aim to protect bona fide purchasers of land plots where real estate objects are located or activities not related to forest use are carried out, relying on EGRN data. In this regard, when a property dispute arises, it is necessary to rely not only on EGRN data regarding the category of a land plot whose private ownership arose before January 1, 2016, but also to examine issues concerning the emergence, formation, and actual use of such a land plot, presence or absence of forest plantations within its boundaries, as well as the legality of acquiring rights to this plot and the bona fides of the acquirer.
Choose a reaction, rate the material, and tell us what could be improved.