Establishing the boundaries of a land plot is an independent method of protection in the case of a dispute regarding the location of boundaries
The requirement to establish land plot boundaries is an independent means of protection aimed at eliminating uncertainty regarding the passage of a land plot boundary when there are objections from an interested party within the procedure for coordinating the location of boundaries.
The Forestry Department (a state-owned institution of a subject of the Russian Federation) refused the company's request to coordinate the location of the land plot boundaries, as part of the forming plot belongs to forest fund lands.
Considering the forestry department's refusal unlawful, the company filed a lawsuit requesting the establishment of land plot boundaries in accordance with the coordinates of turning points specified in the cadastral plan prepared at the company's request. In support of its claim, the company stated that the disputed plot, registered as a previously accounted real estate object, does not belong to a forest plot but is categorized as "agricultural lands."
The first instance court satisfied the company's claims, noting that the parties do not dispute the actual location of the land plot boundaries, but rather have a property dispute resolved in a previously considered case where the company's claim for the absence of the Russian Federation's ownership rights to the land plot granted to its predecessor under perpetual (indefinite) use was satisfied.
The appellate court changed the first instance court's decision and established the land plot boundaries according to the coordinates of turning points determined as a result of judicial expertise.
The cassation court, taking into account the binding decision recognizing the absence of the Russian Federation's ownership rights, overturned the appellate court's judicial act, leaving the first instance court's decision in force.
The Supreme Court's Judicial Panel overturned the cassation court's judicial act and upheld the appellate court's judicial act for the following reasons:
According to paragraph 3 of Article 6 of the Land Code of the Russian Federation, a land plot as an object of ownership and other rights on land is an immovable property that represents part of the earth's surface and has characteristics allowing it to be identified as an individually defined item.
The description of the location of land plot boundaries, in accordance with paragraph 1 and paragraph 3 of paragraph 4 of Article 8 of the Law on Real Estate Registration, is one of the main pieces of information about a real estate object, i.e., characteristics that allow identifying such an immovable property as an individually defined item.
According to the meaning of paragraph 3 of Article 22 of the Law on Real Estate Registration and Articles 39 and paragraph 5 of Article 40 of the Law on Cadastral Activities, the requirement to establish (determine) land plot boundaries is an independent means of protection aimed at eliminating uncertainty regarding the passage of a land plot boundary when there are objections from an interested party, in particular within the procedure for coordinating boundaries.
The result of considering this claim should be a judicial act establishing the adjacent boundary between land plots according to the coordinates of turning points (or by other means provided by legislation). Based on the judicial act, the established boundary is entered into the Unified State Register of Real Estate (EGRN).
According to the case materials, the company's land plot was registered in the cadastral register without surveying and without determining its boundaries or specifying turning points for each part. In a previously considered case, when resolving the dispute over the right to the plot, the issue of its boundaries was not resolved.
Since the forestry department, as an adjacent land user, did not coordinate the boundaries of the named land plot, citing that according to GLR data this plot is part of a forest plot in federal ownership, consisting of lands covered by forest plantations (birch and coniferous trees aged 50 years or older), and falls within the forestry department's boundaries, the court ordered judicial expertise to determine the coordinates of turning points of the land plot boundary and to clarify whether its boundaries intersect with those of adjacent users.
Considering these circumstances and the absence of evidence of transferring forest fund lands to another category, the entry in the state real estate register indicating that the entire disputed plot belongs to agricultural lands does not indicate that the part covered by perennial forest plantations does not belong to the forest fund category.
Choose a reaction, rate the material, and tell us what could be improved.