The location of a land plot within the boundaries of the forest fund in itself does not constitute a basis for the termination of the rights of a bona fide acquirer
In resolving a dispute over land rights, where the claim is based on the land being located within the boundaries of forest fund lands, legally significant circumstances to be established by the court include the formation and actual use of such a land plot, the presence or absence of forest vegetation within its boundaries, the legality of the emergence of rights to this land plot, and the good faith of the acquirer.
The authorized body submitted a request to the citizen requesting recognition of the absence of ownership rights over a land plot partially overlapping with federal forest fund lands by an area of 9 square meters.
Denying satisfaction of the claim, the court based its decision on provisions of paragraph 6 of article 4.6 of the Law on the Introduction into Force of the Land Code of the Russian Federation, paragraph 4 of article 60.2 of the Law on Real Estate Registration, paragraphs 3 and 10 of article 14 of the Law on the Transfer of Lands or Land Plots from One Category to Another, as well as positions expressed by the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation in rulings dated September 21, 2017, No. 1793-O, and February 24, 2022, No. 423-O. According to these provisions, legislators have established a priority for information on land plot categories contained in title documents and the Unified State Register of Real Estate (EGRN), excluding the possibility of arbitrary removal of land plots from citizens who acquired them lawfully (good faith acquirers) solely based on formal grounds of their location within forest districts according to state accounting data.
Considering the arising dispute over rights, among legally significant circumstances are the formation and actual use of the land plot, presence or absence of forest vegetation within its boundaries, legality of the emergence of rights to this land plot, and good faith of the acquirer.
It has been established that the disputed land plot with an area of 1200 square meters from populated areas with a permitted use designation "personal subsidiary farm plot" was formed based on the general plan of the municipal formation, entered into the cadastral register, and allocated to the predecessor of the respondent by the municipal administration through a lease agreement in 2015. Information about the land plot was also entered into the EGRN in 2015. The right to lease the land plot, as well as subsequently the right of ownership, was acquired by the respondent relying on information from the EGRN. The absence of forest vegetation on the disputed plot has been confirmed by an orthophoto map of the period of its formation. A residential house has been built on the land plot by the respondent, it is fenced and used for its intended purpose. The authorized body has not presented evidence of the respondent's bad faith in acquiring the right to the land plot.
Under these circumstances, the court concluded that the respondent acted in good faith and that provisions of paragraph 3 of article 14 of the Law on the Transfer of Lands or Land Plots from One Category to Another, and paragraph 4 of article 60.2 of the Law on Real Estate Registration should be applied with a view to ensuring balance between public and private interests in the disputed relations.
Choose a reaction, rate the material, and tell us what could be improved.