When establishing the fact of partial overlap between boundaries of disputed land plots and boundaries of forest fund lands, the assessment of their possibility for division or modification is carried out taking into account requirements regarding maximum and minimum sizes of formed or modified land plots.
The prosecutor filed a claim in defense of the interests of the Russian Federation against a citizen to remove land plots from state cadastral registration, reclaim them into ownership of the Russian Federation from unlawful possession, and impose an obligation on him to vacate disputed land plots by demolishing residential buildings located thereon.
Reversing the judicial decisions of lower courts, which had fully satisfied the claims, and referring the case for reconsideration, the Judicial Panel of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation pointed out, in particular, the following.
Based on the evidence presented, it has been established that only a part of the area of disputed land plots overlaps with forest fund lands, while the real estate objects (residential buildings) erected by the respondent are located on lands of populated areas, which was not taken into account by the courts when resolving the dispute in accordance with the provisions of Article 301 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation.
According to the justification of the prosecutor's claims, legally significant circumstances that should have been ascertained taking into account the nature of the disputed relations between the parties and applicable material law norms include determining the boundaries of forest fund lands, establishing the fact of inclusion of these lands in the disputed land plots, examining the question of which category of lands the real estate objects erected by the citizen are located on, and determining the possibility of forming a new land plot (or land plots) upon exclusion of forest fund lands from the boundaries of land plots that comply with legislative requirements.
Since the court has established that disputed land plots are only partially located on forest fund lands, the assessment of the possibility of dividing or modifying such land plots should have been carried out taking into account the provisions of Article 11.9 of the Land Code of the Russian Federation, in particular the provisions of paragraphs 1 and 2 of this article regarding maximum and minimum sizes of land plots.
In another case, rejecting the respondent's arguments about the possibility of retaining rights to land plots due to the absence of overlap between their boundaries and forest fund lands, the court relied on the fact that in this case, parts of disputed land plots could not be formed as separate property objects after excluding forest fund lands from their area due to non-compliance with the minimum size requirement for agricultural land established by law of a subject of the Russian Federation in accordance with paragraph 1 of Article 4 of the Federal Law No. 101-FZ dated July 24, 2002 "On Circulation of Agricultural Land."
How useful was this material to you?
Choose a reaction, rate the material, and tell us what could be improved.