Publications

Missing the statute of limitations serves as a basis for refusing to challenge the right to a land plot due to overlap with forest fund lands


Your opinion

Is this topic interesting to you?

Rating

The expiration of the statute of limitations on claims challenging property rights over a land plot based on the overlap of its boundaries with those of forest fund lands, as alleged by the defendant, constitutes grounds for rejecting the claim.

The statute of limitations for claims brought by a public-law entity through an authorized body begins to run from the day when the public-law entity, via the relevant authority, became or should have become aware of the violation of rights over a forested land plot.

The authorized body submitted a claim to citizens requesting the challenge of ownership rights over a land plot, citing its unlawful formation at the expense of forest fund lands.

In making a decision to reject the claims, the court considered that the disputed land plot, categorized as "land for populated areas" with permitted use "for subsistence farming and individual housing construction," was registered in the cadastre in 2017 and, in the same year, was allocated by a local self-government body into joint fractional ownership by the respondents as a large family. The respondents' property rights over the land plot were registered in 2017; the plot is fenced, developed, free of woody vegetation, and an individual residential house is being constructed on it.

Considering the established circumstances of the case, the material-right interest of the plaintiff is directed toward the recovery of property from unlawful possession by others.

The general statute of limitations applies to claims for the recovery of immovable property from unlawful possession. This period begins to run from the day when the public-law entity through authorized bodies became or should have become aware of the violation of their rights and who is the proper defendant in a claim for protection of these rights (Article 200 of the Russian Civil Code).

The authorized body, acting with due diligence, entered information about the "forestry" territorial zone into the Unified State Register of Real Estate (EGRN) in 2019 and could and should have been aware that the boundaries of the land plot belonging to the respondents intersect with those of forest fund lands. By filing a claim with the court in 2024, the authorized body missed the statute of limitations, which the respondents applied, and this, according to the provisions of paragraph 2 of Article 199 of the Russian Civil Code and the legal position of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation outlined in its ruling dated January 28, 2025, No. 3-P, constitutes an independent ground for rejecting the claims.

Source: Thematic Overview of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation No. 11/2026. On the consideration by courts of cases related to rights over land plots of certain categories of lands removed from circulation and restricted in circulation, and their use

Your opinion

How useful was this material to you?

Choose a reaction, rate the material, and tell us what could be improved.

Your impression
Rating
Select a star to rate it