A legal regime for the use of protective forests has been established for each category of protective forests, which must be taken into account when placing objects of non-forest infrastructure.
The placement of electric power network infrastructure objects in forest-park areas is permissible only for energy supply purposes to objects whose placement in these areas is allowed by forestry legislation.
The network organization filed a lawsuit requesting the court to declare unlawful the refusal of the forestry management to issue a permit for the use of part of the land plot located within a forest-park area, intended for placing a cable line aimed at technological connection of an object (a residential house) being constructed outside the forest-park zone.
In satisfying the claim, courts considered that the disputed cable line is not a capital construction object and therefore its placement on a land plot belonging to the category of forest-park areas does not contradict paragraph 5 of part 2 of article 114 of the Forestry Code of the Russian Federation (ЛК РФ).
The judicial panel of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation overturned the court decisions and referred the case for reconsideration due to the following reasons.
Forests located in forest-park areas are protective forests performing functions of protecting natural and other objects (article 10, part 1 of article 111, paragraph 4 of part 1 of article 114 of the Forestry Code). For this category of forests, according to the principles of forestry legislation established in article 1 of the Forestry Code, a legal regime has been established based on their intended purpose, namely: organizing public recreation, preserving sanitary-hygienic and health-improving functions and aesthetic value of natural landscapes.
According to paragraph 5 of part 2 of article 114 of the Forestry Code, the construction of capital construction objects is prohibited in forests located within forest-park areas, except for bicycle, running and other similar tracks and hydraulic engineering structures.
Regarding buildings and structures not classified as capital construction objects, the following should be noted.
In accordance with part 10 of article 21 of the Forestry Code, the Government of the Russian Federation approved by decree No. 999-r dated April 23, 2022 a list of non-capital structures and facilities not related to the creation of forest infrastructure for protective forests, operational forests, and reserve forests. The placement in forest-park areas of linear non-capital objects not related to recreational activities was not provided for in this list during the disputed period.
Based on the permissive type of legal regulation of forestry relations, the placement of electric power network infrastructure objects in forest-park areas is permissible only for energy supply purposes to objects whose placement is allowed by forestry legislation in these areas. Exceptions include objects constructed before the approval of the boundaries of the forest-park area or before the adoption of relevant restrictions.
The argument of the company that laying a cable line through protective forests is necessary for technological connection of the under-construction residential house to the energy supply system and this method is less costly and more convenient for the network organization does not entail an obligation on the part of the management to issue a permit for using the forest land for these purposes.
According to forestry legislation, protective forests may be developed and used only for the purpose of preserving the environment-forming, water protection, protective, sanitary-hygienic, health-improving and other beneficial functions of forests. Therefore, the network company should first resolve the issue of ensuring energy supply through existing networks located outside the forest-park area, including by reconstructing these networks and existing transformer substations.
How useful was this material to you?
Choose a reaction, rate the material, and tell us what could be improved.