Raising capital construction objects on forest land not provided for in the forest development project with a positive state expert conclusion constitutes a significant breach of the lease agreement, grounds for its termination, restoration of the forest land to its original condition, and demolition of unauthorized structures located thereon.
As a result of examining the conditions of forest land use, the regional forestry management identified objects presumably representing capital construction objects with wells installed for extracting natural drinking water for bottling.
In this regard, the management filed a lawsuit requesting that the erected structures on the forest land be recognized as unauthorized constructions, demolished, and the lease agreement with the company terminated.
The company submitted counterclaims against the management requesting a change in the purpose of use of the forest land from the "protective forests" category to the "exploitable forests" category and modification of the lease agreement regarding the permitted use type from "recreational activities" to "geological exploration of mineral deposits and mining of minerals."
The court satisfied the plaintiff's claims but denied the counterclaims for the following reasons.
The forest land leased by the company is located in a forest park zone, the lease agreement was concluded for recreational purposes, and the agreement prohibits placing capital construction objects on the leased area.
The forest development project with a positive state expert conclusion provides for the placement of recreational infrastructure objects (temporary structures) as well as creation of forestry infrastructure objects - fire prevention inventory points and safety in forests information stands. The felling of forest plantations for the purpose of placing planned recreational and forestry infrastructure objects and temporary structures is not provided by the project.
According to the conclusion of judicial land survey expertise, the objects erected by the company are located on the forest land and have characteristics of real estate.
In forests located in forest park zones, exploration and extraction of minerals is prohibited (paragraph 4 of part 2 of Article 114 of the Forest Code of the Russian Federation), as well as placement of capital construction objects, except for bicycle, running and other similar tracks and hydraulic engineering structures (paragraph 5 of part 2 of Article 114 of the Forest Code of the Russian Federation).
Due to the erection on the forest land territory of capital construction objects, as well as the conduct of prohibited (taking into account the purpose and permitted use type of the forest land established by both forestry legislation and the conditions of the lease agreement) activities for mineral extraction by the company, gross violations of essential terms of the lease agreement have been committed, which constitutes grounds for its judicial termination, restoration of the forest land to its original condition, and demolition of unauthorized structures located thereon.
How useful was this material to you?
Choose a reaction, rate the material, and tell us what could be improved.