Publications

Legal regime of forests


Your opinion

Is this topic interesting to you?

Rating

Test yourself

Право

Short questions will help you recall the key points of the document.

Loading questions…

Navigation

General Provisions

The legal regime of forests in the Russian Federation establishes a legal basis for the use, protection, preservation, and reproduction of forests, taking into account their ecological, economic, and social significance. Forests occupy about 70% of the country's territory and are a key natural resource ensuring the maintenance of ecological balance, oxygen regeneration, and biodiversity conservation. In accordance with the Forest Code of the Russian Federation (FC RF), forest legislation is regulated at the federal and regional levels, as well as by decrees of the President and government resolutions of the Russian Federation, while normative acts of executive authorities and local self-government bodies must not contradict federal legislation.

The legal regime of forests includes defining their legal status as an ecological system and a natural resource. Forests are considered not only as a collection of vegetation, but also as a biological complex with territorial unity, which ensures their sustainable functioning. The main principles of forest use include multi-purpose, rational, continuous, and non-exhaustive utilization, while taking into account the requirements for conservation and reproduction of forest resources and biodiversity.

The legislation regulates the rights and obligations of citizens and legal entities when using forests for economic activities, harvesting forest food resources, and collecting medicinal plants. For example, the right to collect forest resources is accompanied by restrictions on methods of harvesting, timelines, and norms established by the forestry regulation, taking into account the need to preserve biodiversity. Judicial practice confirms that non-compliance with these requirements, as in the case of harvesting birch mushrooms (chaga) in the Republic of Tuva, serves as a basis for refusing to issue permits for the removal of forest resources.

Thus, the legal regime of forests ensures a comprehensive approach to their use and protection: it regulates property and usage relations, establishes restrictions and obligations for forest users, enshrines measures for protection against fires, harmful organisms, and pollution, as well as creates conditions for forest regeneration and sustainable development of the forest fund. This regime is aimed at preserving the ecosystem integrity of forests and ensuring their rational use in the interests of society and the state.

As noted in the state report "On the State and Protection of the Environment of the Russian Federation in 2010"1, the forest fund of the Russian Federation covers about 70% of the land area and is the most important stabilizing natural complex in the country. Forests have been and remain the main type of vegetation cover over vast areas of Russia. The total area of land in the Russian Federation covered by forests amounted to 1,183.7 million hectares as of January 1, 2010 (an increase of 5.1 million hectares compared to 2009), including the area of forest fund lands – 1,143.5 million hectares (an increase of 8.8 million hectares). In eco-legal science, the South American rainforest and Siberian taiga are referred to as the "lungs of the planet"2, thereby emphasizing the important role of forests in ensuring a favorable state of the environment through oxygen regeneration.

Forest legislation3, as well as issues of ownership, use and disposal of natural resources (including forests)4 are within the joint jurisdiction of the Russian Federation and the subjects of the Russian Federation. The relevant provisions of the Constitution of the Russian Federation are clarified in Article 2 of the Forest Code of the Russian Federation. This article also establishes that forest legislation consists of the Forest Code of the Russian Federation, other federal laws, and laws adopted by the subjects of the Russian Federation in accordance with them.

Forest relations may also be regulated by the President of the Russian Federation's decrees, which must not contradict the Forest Code of the Russian Federation (LC RF), other federal laws. The Government of the Russian Federation issues regulatory legal acts regulating forest relations within the scope of authority defined by the LC RF, other federal laws, as well as the President of the Russian Federation's decrees. Federal executive authorities issue regulatory legal acts regulating forest relations in cases provided for by the LC RF, other federal laws, as well as the President of the Russian Federation's decrees, and Government of the Russian Federation decisions.

On the basis of and in compliance with the Forest Code of the Russian Federation, other federal laws, laws of the subjects of the Russian Federation, decrees of the President of the Russian Federation, and government resolutions, executive authorities of the subjects of the Russian Federation within their powers may issue normative legal acts regulating forest relations. On the basis of and in compliance with the Forest Code of the Russian Federation, other federal laws, laws of the subjects of the Russian Federation, decrees of the President of the Russian Federation, and government resolutions, local self-government bodies within their powers may issue municipal legal acts regulating forest relations.

Alongside the Forest Code of the Russian Federation, the main federal laws determining the legal regime of forests include: the Federal Law "On Environmental Protection" (which defines the legal regime for all components of the natural environment, including forests); the Federal Law "On Fire Safety"5.

In the previously applicable Forest Code of the Russian Federation of 1997, regulation of forest relations was carried out taking into account the concept of a forest as a collection of forest vegetation, land, wildlife and other components of the surrounding natural environment having important ecological, economic and social significance6.

According to the current Forest Code of the Russian Federation, the use, protection, conservation and reproduction of forests are carried out based on the concept of a forest as an ecological system or as a natural resource (Article 5 of the Forest Code of the Russian Federation). According to Yu.I. Shupleiko's opinion, this definition has lost the main meaning—the key element that allows several plants to be combined under the general concept of "forest." This common element is biological and territorial unity. Plants growing on a limited territory, representing a single biological complex, form the basis of all forests7.

Judicial Practice

The refusal to issue a conclusion (permittive document) for the export of forest food resources is lawful if the harvesting of such resources has been carried out in violation of requirements regarding the conservation and reproduction of biodiversity on the forested area.

The business entity applied to Rospridnadzor with an application for the issuance of a conclusion (permittive document) for the export beyond the territory of the Russian Federation of birch mushrooms (chaga), belonging to the company and harvested on lands of the forest fund.

Following the consideration of the application, Rospridnadzor made a decision to refuse the issuance of the conclusion, motivated by non-compliance with the conditions established by legislation for harvesting, which are intended to ensure the conservation and reproduction of biodiversity of forest resources of the Russian Federation.

Disagreeing with the refusal to issue the conclusion, the company challenged this decision in court.

The decision of the first instance court, left unchanged by the appellate and cassation courts, recognized the refusal to issue the conclusion as lawful on the following grounds.

In accordance with the current legal regulation within the Eurasian Economic Union, placing wild live animals and (or) wild-growing plants under the customs procedure of export is carried out upon submission to the customs authority of a member state of a license. To obtain this license, applicants must submit documents confirming the legality of the preparation, collection, hunting or capture and (or) ownership of wild live animals and (or) wild-growing plants.

Pursuant to paragraph 1 of Article 12 of the Forest Code of the Russian Federation, forest use is carried out in order to ensure their multi-purpose, rational, continuous, non-exhaustive use, as well as the development of the forestry complex. According to paragraph 4 of paragraph 1 of Article 25 of the Forest Code of the Russian Federation, types of forest use include the preparation of food resources and the collection of medicinal plants.

The rights and obligations of citizens and legal entities engaged in the use of forests for the harvesting of forest food resources and the collection of medicinal plants are established by the Rules for Harvesting Forest Food Resources and Collecting Medicinal Plants (approved by the order of the Ministry of Natural Resources of Russia dated July 28, 2020 No. 494, hereinafter referred to as the "Harvesting Rules"), in accordance with paragraph 6 of Article 81 of the Russian Federation Forest Code.

Paragraphs 13 and 15 of the Harvesting Rules establish restrictions according to which the harvesting of certain types of forest resources and medicinal plants may be carried out strictly by a specific method and within established timeframes, taking into account the norms and parameters set by the forestry operational regulations, as well as based on the actual availability of resources in the territory of a particular forest district, while considering the requirements for conservation and reproduction of biodiversity.

The birch mushroom (chaga) is an object of civil rights, restricted in circulation according to the meaning of paragraph 2 of Article 129 of the Russian Civil Code. For the purposes of movement across the customs border, a permit-based procedure has been established. At the same time, the realization of the forest user's right to use forest resources cannot be carried out without taking into account the need to preserve the biodiversity of forest resources. A permit for the export of birch mushrooms from the Russian Federation may be issued only if their harvesting was carried out without violating the requirements for preserving and reproducing biodiversity on the relevant forest area.

As a result of the inspection conducted by Rosprirodnadzor, based on information received from the Republic of Tuva (the location where the food forest resource was harvested), it has been established that the possible annual volume of birch mushroom (chaga) harvesting on the forest area is unreasonably overestimated. Harvesting chaga in larger quantities is not possible, as due to the biological characteristics of its growth, the restoration of resources on the same area is possible only after 15 years.

Taking into account that such a resource is physically absent on the forested land, Rosprirondrazor came to a lawful conclusion that the implementation of the forest user's right to use forest resources in this case does not ensure achieving the goal of preserving biodiversity, which served as the basis for refusing to issue a permit for the removal of the mushroom.

Source: Overview of judicial practice on issues of applying environmental protection legislation (approved by the Presidium of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation on 24.06.2022)

  1. State report «On the state and protection of the environment of the Russian Federation in 2010» [Electronic resource]. 2010. URL: http://www.mnr.gov.ru/regulatory/detail.php?ID=128153. ↩

  2. Environmental law: textbook / ed. by S.A. Bogolyubov. Moscow, 2010. P. 9. ↩

  3. Constitution of the Russian Federation. Art. 72. ↩

  4. Constitution of the Russian Federation. Art. 72. ↩

  5. Federal Law of December 21, 1994 No. 69-FZ "On Fire Safety" // RSZ RF. 1994. No. 35. Art. 3649. ↩

  6. Preamble of the Forest Code of the Russian Federation: 22-FZ. 1997. ↩

  7. Institutions of Environmental Law / ed. by S.A. Bogolyubov. Moscow, 2010. Pp. 332–333. ↩

Your opinion

How useful was this material to you?

Choose a reaction, rate the material, and tell us what could be improved.

Your impression
Rating
Select a star to rate it