Legal regime of certain categories of land
Is this topic interesting to you?
Test yourself
Право
Short questions will help you recall the key points of the document.
Loading questions…
Test yourself
Short questions will help you recall the key points of the document.
Loading questions…
The legal regime of land is the order of possible and required behavior towards land established by legal norms.
The prosecutor filed a claim to prohibit the activity of extracting clayey soil on an agricultural land plot.
The court established that a person whose main type of activity is the production of bricks, tiles and other building products made from fired clay is conducting the extraction of clayey soil on an agricultural land plot. The use of mineral resources is carried out on the basis of a license with targeted purpose and types of work - exploration of deposits with simultaneous extraction of brick clays.
The court's decision satisfied the prosecutor's claims, prohibiting the individual from engaging in activities related to the extraction of brick clays on agricultural land plots until the land plots are reclassified into a category that allows for the extraction of minerals.
The appellate court overturned the decision and denied satisfaction of the prosecutor's claims.
Leaving the first instance court's decision in force, the cassation court noted the following.
In accordance with Article 42 of the Land Code of the Russian Federation, landowners and individuals who are not landowners are obliged to: use land plots in accordance with their designated purpose using methods that should not cause harm to the environment, including land as a natural object; prevent pollution, depletion, degradation, damage, destruction of lands and soils, and other negative impact on lands and soils.
According to paragraph 1 of Article 78 of the Russian Federation Land Code, agricultural lands may be used for agricultural production, creation of protective forest plantings, scientific research, educational and other purposes related to agricultural production, as well as for aquaculture (fish farming) purposes.
Thus, an agricultural land plot can be used for activities related to the extraction of minerals only after transferring this plot from the specified category. Until that moment, its legal regime of use is limited by the target purpose in accordance with Articles 42 and 78 of the Russian Federation Land Code.
At the same time, the mere presence of a company's license for mineral use does not exempt it from the obligation to comply with land legislation and does not grant the right to carry out the extraction of common minerals on agricultural land plots.
Rejecting the respondent's argument regarding the use of commonly occurring useful minerals extracted on a land plot owned by the company for its own needs in accordance with Article 19 of the Mineral Resources Law, the court noted that under this article, the use of commonly occurring useful minerals for one's own needs refers to their utilization by landowners, land users, landholders, and lessees of land plots for personal, household, and other purposes not related to entrepreneurial activities, whereas the company uses the extracted silty clay from an agricultural land plot in its production activities1.
The supervisory authority in the field of natural resource use filed a lawsuit with the court requesting a ban on economic activities related to the extraction of common mineral resources on sites of deposits, partially and (or) fully located within the water protection zone of Lake Baikal. The basis for filing the lawsuit was the non-fulfillment of the recommendation by the East-Baikal inter-district environmental prosecution to eliminate violations of federal legislation, manifested in the continuation of activities related to the extraction of minerals in the central ecological zone and the water protection zone of Lake Baikal.
The subsoil user opposed the satisfaction of the claim, arguing that licenses for the extraction of common mineral resources were issued prior to the establishment of the boundaries of the water protection zone of Lake Baikal.
By a decision of the first instance court, left unchanged by the appellate and cassation courts, the claim was fully satisfied on the following grounds.
On the Baikal Natural Territory, a special regime of economic and other activities is established, carried out in accordance with the principles of priority for types of activities that do not lead to disruption of the unique ecological system of Lake Baikal and natural landscapes within its water protection zone. Activities that have a negative impact on the unique ecological system of Lake Baikal are prohibited or restricted (Article 5 and paragraph 1 of Article 6 of the Federal Law of May 1, 1999 No. 94-FZ "On the Protection of Lake Baikal", hereinafter referred to as the Baikal Law).
In accordance with the provisions of paragraph 1 of Article 3 and paragraph 3 of Article 6 of the Baikal Law, the Government of the Russian Federation shall approve the boundaries of the Baikal Natural Territory and ecological zones (central ecological zone, buffer ecological zone, atmospheric influence ecological zone), as well as a list of activities prohibited in the central ecological zone.
In exercising the aforementioned powers, the Government of the Russian Federation established that the extraction of minerals on the territory of Lake Baikal, within its water protection zone, in the channels of spawning rivers and their water protection zones, except for the extraction of groundwater for drinking and household water supply purposes, as well as dredging works, is prohibited (ninth paragraph of the Order dated August 30, 2001 No. 643 "On Approval of a List of Activities Prohibited in the Central Ecological Zone of the Baikal Natural Territory," which was in effect during the period of the dispute).
Based on the main principles of environmental protection, including the presumption of ecological danger associated with planned economic and other activities, courts have concluded that further conduct by the company in the extraction of minerals within the water protection zone of Lake Baikal based on the existing license is impermissible.
This would constitute a violation of environmental legislation and the protection regime for Lake Baikal, which is classified as a UNESCO World Heritage Site2.
Choose a reaction, rate the material, and tell us what could be improved.