Fencing of forest land is allowed only in cases provided by law, provided there is a positive conclusion from the state expertise of the forest development project.
The prosecutor, acting in the interests of the Russian Federation, a subject of the Russian Federation, or an indeterminate group of persons, submitted requirements to the lessee of the forest land, demanding that they be obligated to dismantle the fencing.
It has been established that a lease agreement for forest land from the category of protective forests was concluded between the authorized body of a subject of the Russian Federation and an individual entrepreneur for the purpose of conducting recreational activities. This agreement, in particular, provides the lessee with the right to place certain temporary structures, except for the installation of fencing.
The forest development project, which received a positive conclusion from the state expertise, does not provide for the construction of such non-forest infrastructure as fencing on the forest land used by the respondent.
Nevertheless, it has been established that the disputed forest land located in the water protection zone has wooden fencing over one meter high along its outer perimeter on three sides, restricting access to citizens and passage of wild animals.
In satisfying the submitted requirements, the court relied on the fact that the legislature, establishing a special legal regime for forest fund lands, enshrined in Article 11 of the Forest Code of the Russian Federation (LC RF) both the right of citizens to freely and gratuitously stay in forests (Part 1), as well as guarantees for the implementation of this right by establishing a prohibition on persons who have been granted forest land from preventing access of citizens to these forest lands, as well as fencing them, except in cases provided by legislation (Part 8).
Fencing of forest lands allocated for agricultural activities is allowed, except for those located in green zones (Part 2 of Article 38, paragraph 2 of Part 4 of Article 114 of the Forest Code of the Russian Federation), allocated for activities in the hunting industry (Part 4 of Article 36 of the Forest Code of the Russian Federation), as well as in forest park areas for the purpose of protecting forests (Part 3 of Article 114 of the Forest Code of the Russian Federation).
Fencing of forest lands allocated for recreational activities is not provided by the forest legislation.
Similarly, the court did not establish grounds provided by law under which, in accordance with Parts 4 and 5 of Article 11 of the Forest Code of the Russian Federation, it would be possible to prohibit or restrict the presence of citizens on the disputed forest land.
III. Disputes regarding land plots,
located within the shore zone of a water
object of public use
How useful was this material to you?
Choose a reaction, rate the material, and tell us what could be improved.